Why your one-time link says it was already opened
3 min read
You create a one-time link, send it, and your colleague replies: "It says the secret is gone." Sometimes the explanation is harmless. Sometimes it is not. Here is how to tell the difference.
Link previews and scanners
Many tools open links automatically, without any human clicking:
- Chat apps fetch a link to build a preview card.
- Email security gateways follow links to check them for phishing and malware.
- Corporate proxies and antivirus tools scan downloads and pages.
If a one-time link reveals and deletes the secret as soon as the page is requested, these automated visits use up the secret before the real recipient arrives.
How One-Time Link avoids this
Opening a link on One-Time Link only loads a confirmation page. The secret is retrieved, and deleted, only when a person presses the "Reveal secret" button. Link previewers and most scanners do not press buttons, so they do not consume the secret.
If the secret is still gone
Automated tools that fully render pages and click buttons exist, and so does human error. If your recipient says the link no longer works:
- Ask whether they opened it already, perhaps on another device.
- If not, assume someone else may have seen the secret. Change the password or revoke the key.
- Create a new link and send it through a different channel.
Tips for sending links
- Prefer a short expiry so a leaked link is useful for as little time as possible.
- Tell the recipient to expect the link, so that an unexpected "already opened" message gets noticed quickly.
- Avoid pasting links into public or widely shared channels.